Read About What We Love: Web Development & Technologies

Safe Commenting with the Page Comments Plugin for Umbraco

We have been working with Umbraco and find that this open source Content Management System (CMS) is one of the best in the business. With a 200,000 strong community that is working on making it better than before always, and its nature of being highly customizable makes it a great choice us and our clients. As more and more companies choose this CMS, its popularity automatically translates to more exchanges with readers and web users, making its websites highly interactive.

While we appreciate the conveniences and the malleability of the CMS that make it extremely user-friendly, we found that there is some room for change in a few areas. One of the glitches we struggled with was that Umbraco currently lacks the feature of being able to add comments on pages or manage comments without third party vendors.

Third Party Security Concerns

Third party vendors sometimes engage in security violations by mining users’ data and selling them to advertisers. This is an unfortunate yet blatant reality of the virtual world’s business model. Third party vendors whose plugins are used on your website are likely to have access to the email addresses of those who comment on your pages posing the risk of data misuse and other security concerns. The Disqus security breach in December 2013 is an example of the risks that come with third-party comment management widgets. 29 million comments from Disqus were downloaded and the addresses of anonymous commenters were accessed by a leading Swedish Newspaper, Expressen.

We were therefore very keen on protecting the interest and privacy of those who visit and comment on our pages. To overcome this security hassle, we were looking for a solution where user information would not be compromised as well as comments are moderated with ease. While we found very few such plugins, they didn’t suit our needs. So, we decided to develop our own plugin for this use. And share it as well!

Managing Comments

The Page Comments Plugin apart from enabling comments on any pages, makes managing them a breeze. As websites and blogs increase in popularity and have a lot of comments it often becomes challenging to handle a large volume of responses and comments. Imagine having to go through each one of the hundreds or sometimes thousands of comments you receive. Moderating every comment – accepting or rejecting pending comments; flagging, removing spam, banning users etc. will not just be time-consuming, but in some cases will be impossible.

With our new plugin for Umbraco, comments can be moderated and managed in one go. The display and interface allow for quick and effective moderation of comments as bulk, provide email information of comments, as well as give you the option of auto-approving comments.  

Pulling the Plug on Spam

An all-pervasive problem in the comment sections is a dreaded four letter word that can ruin the liveliest of discussions – Spam. While websites try to stay on top of the game by being cautious about spam, spammers often catch up quickly changing their methods.

This makes it that much more important to have direct control over your comments and to manage them in a way that reduces spam. Moderators must delete and flag suspicious comments and even ban such users. Effective comment moderation over a period of time increases the accuracy of your comment management. The Page Comments Plugin works as a great tool to do just that and keep your comment section healthy and spam-free greatly reducing the risk of spam due to third party widgets. It provides the option of easily customising and incorporating a spam checker in the comments section. It comes with the Google reCAPTCHA 2.0 System that allows for spam to be at bay.

The Page Comments Plugin can be downloaded in English or French. However, additional languages can be extended by adding translation files. The comment forms, validation messages and labels of the public pages are multi-lingual, changing automatically based on the website language settings, so users can comment easily.

Have you faced some security concerns with a third-party comments plugin? Give the Page Comments Plugin a try and let us know what you think. Here’s where you can

Here’s where you can download and install this latest Plugin.

Key Features:

  • Enable comments on pages and blogs
  • Reduce spam with the incorporation of Google reCAPTCHA 2.0.
  • Check misuse of personal data of commenters
  • Manage comments as bulk, saving time and energy
  • Receive convenient emailer with comment information
  • Compatible with Umbraco Versions 7+

Elizabeth Raj| Blogger



Jakaria Ahmed Shimul
I have tried this one. But From my site it shows "Your comment is not submitted. Try after some time." please help
3/7/2019 10:17:27 AM
Your blog is very nice... Thanks for sharing your information...
4/27/2018 7:23:50 AM
Nice plugin, I got it up and running quite fast. The only thing I cannot figure out i how to get back to the published comments, if I would later want to delete a published comment or delete a comment published with auto approval.
3/11/2018 2:49:04 PM
Gaja Digital Agency
Thank you for your feedback, Srikanth!
11/16/2017 5:32:35 AM
nice plugin
11/16/2017 5:26:41 AM
Punam, Community Manager - Gaja Digital
Thank You Martin for your comment. We appreciate your feedback. The comments plugin has been created to cater the needs of small and medium-sized websites and the comments are a small part of the page it is made on. While testing the plugin, we found no impact on the performance of a website even if the website has more than 200 pages and each page has more than 300 comments. However, you pointed out correctly that if a website has more than 1000 pages and each page has more than 500 comments, performance maybe a bit of concern, but there are hardly such heavy websites on Umbraco (about 1%). The example you mentioned fits best for an active forum, which receives many comments constantly, in that case it is better to have separate database tables to store comments. Thank you! Keep reading!
2/8/2017 6:48:45 AM
thanks for nice work, overall it seems good, but the only weak point i see, is the core of your comment system, it uses umbraco content, and as content is valuable, using that for comenting is not right choice imagine my site produce 1000 pages per year, but it would have about 50,000 comments!
2/6/2017 3:17:28 PM
Punam, Community Manager - Gaja Digital
Thanks Sherin for sharing your feedback!
1/30/2017 9:38:21 AM
This is a good article about "page comments plugin". Nice Post It’s really helpful for me....!!!!
1/30/2017 9:19:09 AM
Punam, Community Manager - Gaja Digital
Thanks Morten for trying out the 'Page Comments Plugin.' We are sorry, you couldn't get it to work in the beginning but all's well that ends well :) We'll appreciate your feedback! Thanks and Regards, Team Gaja Digital
1/2/2017 3:42:34 AM
Morten S
It's working now :)
12/30/2016 2:08:52 PM
Morten S
Hello I'm trying to use this on my website, but can't get it to work. When i test it and write a comment, it says "Your comment is not submitted. Try after some time." I followed your guide, but cant get it to work. hope someone can help me :)
12/30/2016 1:52:58 PM

Leave A Comment

Transform your business

We'll get in touch with you ASAP!

Contact us